>Earth Stewardship Discussion
Home » Teaching » SAS 004Y : Water in Popular Culture » Syllabus » Earth Stewardship Discussion
In this Section: SAS004 Introduction » Water Scarcity » Water Scarcity Discussion » Floods » Flood Insurance Discussion » Water Quality » Water Quality Discussion » Water & Psychology » Water Psychology Discussion » Conquering Nature » Conquering Nature Discussion » Pro Poor Water » Pro Poor Water Discussion » Arctic Socio-Ecology » Indigenous Knowledge » Earth Stewardship » Earth Stewardship Discussion » Global Climate Change » Global Climate Change Discussion » Coastal Zone in Crisis » Coastal Zone Crisis Discussion » Course Review

Earth Stewardship Discussion

Hydropower to Reduce Reliance on Fossil Fuels Even If It Destroys River Ecosystems?

Background:

There is a saying, “Think Global, Act Local”. However, what if acting locally makes global problems worse, or acting globally makes local problems worse? Just such a complicated trade-off appears to be at play in the approach different countries have taken to either (a) combat global climate change by dramatically increasing dam construction and flow regulation for renewable hydropower or (b) combat river ecosystem degradation or collapse by removing dams and/or significantly reducing flow regulation.

According to Manibo (2016), “Hydropower projects are accepted by the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change under its Clean Development Mechanism, which allows such projects to generate carbon credits.” As a result most nations around the world are planning to build more dams in their efforts to increase electrical capacity and reduce fossil fuel dependence. Some scientists advocate that hydropower saves far more greenhouse gas emissions than it creates. Although these pro-dam scientists recognize that dams harm local rivers, they believe that these effects can be mitigated through investments in river science and engineering to enhance dammed rivers.

Meanwhile, many scientists and non-governmental organizations report that dams emit large amounts greenhouse gases, especially where most are being built in the tropics, and their other problems cannot be mitigated.  In the United States, a growing number of dams are being entirely removed, because they are deemed to cause too many problems and have harmed the river ecosystem too much. In recent years, industrial solar power has become less expensive than fossil fuel power, even including the cost of battery systems. The cost of wind power is also declining rapidly. Thus, many people argue that adoption of solar and wind power can eventually replace not only fossil fuels but also hydropower.  Whether that is the case or not is speculative, because the known total supply of “rare Earth elements” necessary to construct solar panels may be too limiting.

The question arises, Shall humanity build more dams to reduce dependence on fossil fuels or remove more dams to restore more rivers to a health ecosystem?

Different stakeholders have different perspectives on this issue.

Broad Assignment:

Fundamentally, this question revolves around the idea that humanity can swing the status of the global environmental and wholesale ecosystems through its conscious action, whether to build or remove tens of thousands of dams. To get a glimpse of such massive ecosystem engineering, you will watch the movie Salmon Fishing in the Yemen to view a dramatized, fictional perspective on an effort to change a river’s flows and fish population into different regimes. After watching the movie but before coming to your discussion section, everybody will read an article describing the anticipated boom in river dam construction. Further, after watching the movie but before coming to your discussion section, each person will be assigned to a stakeholder viewpoint and you will read a document presenting the viewpoint you are assigned to articulate. In class you will participate in discussion of the scenario.

Everybody reads:

  • Zarfl, C., Lumsdon, A.E., Berlekamp, J., Tydecks, L, Tockner, K. 2015. A global boom in hydropower dam construction. Aquatic Sciences 77: 161-170.
    • Note that this item cannot be shared publicly, but is available through UCD's online journal access rights. Please obtain this from the SAS004 Canvas Files pages or by downloading it directly from the journal from a UCD-hosted internet connection. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00027-014-0377-0

Stakeholder ID’s For This Assignment:

  1. United Nations
  2. Dam Construction Advocate
  3. Pro-Rivers Non-Governmental Organization
  4. Dam Removal Scientist

Specific Readings by Stakeholder ID:

You are welcome to search the internet to find more resources in support of discussing the viewpoint you are assigned to represent.

1.     Read the United Nations article, “How Hydropower Can Help Climate Action”.

2.     Muller, M. 2019. Dams have the power to slow climate change. Nature 566-315-318.

Note that this item cannot be shared publicly, but is available through UCD's online journal access rights. Please obtain this from the SAS004 Canvas Files pages or by downloading it directly from the journal from a UCD-hosted internet connection.

3.    Manibo, M. 2016. Are Mega Dams a Solution or Burden to Climate Change

https://www.internationalrivers.org/resources/are-mega-dams-asolution-or-burden-to-climate-change-eco-business-11471

4.     Magilligan, F.J., Graber, B.E., Nislow, K.H., Chipman, J.W., Sneddon, C.S., Fox, C.A. 2016. River restoration by dam removal: Enhancing connectivity at watershed scales. Elema Science of the Anthropocene 4: 000108.

https://www.elementascience.org/articles/10.12952/journal.elementa.000108/?utm_source=TrendMD&utm_medium=cpc&utm_campaign=TrendMD_Element

Activity in Discussion Section:

  • 10 minutes settling class down, deal with class issues, and TA intro to scenario.
  • 10 minutes discussion with same all people with same viewpoint discussing how to make your main points
  • 10 minutes with an opposing viewpoint, one-on-one
  • 10 minutes with an opposing viewpoint, one-one-one
  • 10 minutes whole-class discussion wrap up.

Literature Cited

Manibo, M. 2016. Are Mega Dams a Solution or Burden to Climate Change? https://www.internationalrivers.org/resources/are-mega-dams-asolution-or-burden-to-climate-change-eco-business-11471

In this Section: SAS004 Introduction » Water Scarcity » Water Scarcity Discussion » Floods » Flood Insurance Discussion » Water Quality » Water Quality Discussion » Water & Psychology » Water Psychology Discussion » Conquering Nature » Conquering Nature Discussion » Pro Poor Water » Pro Poor Water Discussion » Arctic Socio-Ecology » Indigenous Knowledge » Earth Stewardship » Earth Stewardship Discussion » Global Climate Change » Global Climate Change Discussion » Coastal Zone in Crisis » Coastal Zone Crisis Discussion » Course Review
>Earth Stewardship Discussion
  • Home
  • About Me
  • Research
    • Scientific Highlights
    • Projects
      • Near-Census River Science
        • 2DMUs
        • Hydraulic Topography
        • Topographic Change Detection
        • Topographic Change Processes
        • Floodplain Inundation
        • Streamwood Storage
        • Upper South Yuba
        • Salmonid Migration
        • North Yuba River
        • Salmon Migratory Habitat
      • Geomorphic Covariance Structures
      • Synthetic River Valleys
      • Watershed Processes
        • Watershed Sediment Transport
        • Watershed Streamwood
        • Watershed Sedimentation
      • River Rehabilitation
        • Spawning Habitat Rehabilitation
        • Cobble/Gravel Injection
        • Streamwood Jams
        • Geomorphologist's Guide
      • Waterfalls
        • Horseshoe Falls
        • NSEAM 1.0
        • Hydraulic Jumps
        • Small Step Mapping
        • Small Step Hydraulics
      • Tidal Freshwater Deltas
        • TFD Introduction
        • TFD Vegetation
        • TFD Sediment Cycles
        • TFD Ecogeomorphology
        • TFD Hydrometeorology
        • TFD Sediment Transport
        • TFD Modeling
        • TFD Animal Response
        • Bush River, MD
        • Winter's Run, MD
      • Estuarine Processes
        • Salinas River Estuary
        • San Joaquin-Sacramento Delta
        • Blackwater National Wildlife Refuge
        • Long Island Sound
      • Functional Flows Model
      • Volcanic Lakes
        • VL Classification & Modeling
        • VL Bibliography
        • Keli Mutu
          • Remote Sampling Strategy
        • Lake Batur
        • Other Volcanic Lakes
      • Agricultural Sediment
      • Urban Rivers
      • Chaos in Hydrology
      • Channel Types
    • Methods
      • Net Sedimentation Tile (NST) Protocol
      • Sediment Core Processing Protocol
      • Vibracoring Protocol
      • Loss-On-Ignition Protocol
      • C-14 Sample Selection and Prep Protocol
      • Cation Sample Prep and Analysis Protocol
      • Grain Size Distirbution Protocol
      • MS Word Fig. code
      • Kite Blimp Method
      • Laser Granulometer Protocol
    • Software
      • River Builder
    • Sponsors
  • Teaching
    • SAS 004Y : Water in Popular Culture
      • Course Logistics
      • Sections
      • Syllabus
        • SAS004 Introduction
        • Water Scarcity
        • Water Scarcity Discussion
        • Floods
        • Flood Insurance Discussion
        • Water Quality
        • Water Quality Discussion
        • Water & Psychology
        • Water Psychology Discussion
        • Conquering Nature
        • Conquering Nature Discussion
        • Pro Poor Water
        • Pro Poor Water Discussion
        • Arctic Socio-Ecology
        • Indigenous Knowledge
        • Earth Stewardship
        • Earth Stewardship Discussion
        • Global Climate Change
        • Global Climate Change Discussion
        • Coastal Zone in Crisis
        • Coastal Zone Crisis Discussion
        • Course Review
      • Readings
      • Instructor
      • Classroom Behavior
      • Grading Policy
      • Movie Logs
      • Discussion Activities
      • Expository Essay
      • Study Guide
      • Online TA Help
    • ESM 125: River Conservation
      • Syllabus
        • River Conservation Introduction
        • Navigability For Title - Law
        • River Segmentation
        • Historical Hydrology
        • Indigenous River Conservation
        • Habitat Conservation Law
        • Aquatic Habitat
        • Riparian Habitat
        • Water Temperature
        • Sediment Sampling
        • Water Quality
        • CA State Water Boards
        • Biological Opinions
        • Setting Biological Goals
        • County-Level Water Management
        • River Restoration
        • Fish Passage & Fishways
        • Beaver-Assisted Restoration
        • Water Management Lessons
      • Instructor
      • Grading Policy
      • Readings
      • Exams
      • Individual Assignments
      • River Presentations
      • Video Response Canvas Quizzes
      • Reading Response Canvas Quizzes
    • HYD 143 : Ecohydrology
      • Instructor
      • Grading Policy
      • Syllabus
        • Chapter 1
        • Chapter 2
        • Chapter 3
        • Chapter 4
        • Chapter 5
        • Group Activity 1
        • Group Presentations 1
        • Chapter 6
        • Chapter 7
        • Chapter 8
        • Chapter 9
        • Group Activity 2
        • Group Presentations 2
        • Chapter 10
        • Chapter 11
        • Chapter 12
        • Chapter 13
        • Chapter 14
        • Chapter 15
        • Group Activity 3
        • Group Presentations 3
        • Chapter 16
        • Chapter 17
        • Chapter 18
        • Chapter 19
        • Chapter 20
        • Chapter 21
      • Online TA Help
      • Video Response Quizzes
      • Group Presentations
      • In-class Assignments
    • HYD 151 : Field Methods in Hydrology
      • Instructor
      • TA Info
      • Grading Policy
      • Syllabus
        • Chapter 21
        • Chapter 1
        • Chapter 2
        • Chapter 3
        • Chapter 4
        • Assignment 1
        • Chapter 5
        • Chapter 6
        • Assignment 2
        • Chapter 7
        • Chapter 8
        • Chapter 9
        • Assignment 3
        • Chapter 10
        • Chapter 12
        • Chapter 11
        • Chapter 13
        • Chapter 14
        • Assignment 4
        • Chapter 15
        • Chapter 16
        • Chapter 16b
        • Chapter 17
        • Field Equipment Showcase
        • Chapter 18
        • Chapter 19
        • Chapter 20
        • Chapter 22
        • Chapter 23
        • Chapter 24
        • Course Review
      • Readings
      • Online TA Help
      • Field Safety
    • HYD 252: Hillslope Geomorphology and Sediment Budgets
      • Instructor
      • Grading Policy
      • Syllabus
        • Week 1
        • Week 2
        • Week 3
        • Week 5
        • Week 6
        • Week 7
        • Week 8
        • Week 9
        • Week 10
        • Week 4
      • Readings
      • Safety
    • HYD 254Y: Ecohydraulics
      • Instructor
      • Grading Policy
      • Syllabus
        • Introduction to Near-Census River Science
        • Introduction to 2D Modeling
        • 2D Modeling Training
        • 2D modeling discussion & synthesis
        • 2D Modeling Terrain Variability
        • 2D Model Validation
        • Fluvial Landform Assessment
        • Ecological Analysis of Structure and Function
        • Hydrogeomorphic Processes
        • Parameterizing Boundary Roughness
        • Frontiers of River Science
      • Readings
      • Online TA Help
      • Lab Tutorials
    • HYD 256: Geomorphology of Estuaries and Deltas
      • Syllabus
        • Week 1
        • Week 2
        • Week 3
        • Week 4
        • Week 5
        • Week 6
        • Week 7
        • Week 8
        • Week 9
        • Week 10
      • Readings
      • Lab
      • Field Safety
      • Online TA Help
      • Grading Policy
    • Virtual River Methods
      • Syllabus
      • Instructor
      • Grading Policy
      • Readings
      • Assignments
      • Game Setup
  • People
    • MS Students
    • PhD Students
    • Postdocs
    • Committee Advisees
    • Technicians
    • Undergrads
    • Visitors
    • Collaborators
    • Furry Friends
  • Info for Applicants
  • Service
    • Past Service
    • Professional Service
  • Outreach
  • Curriculum Vitae

GET IN TOUCH

  • 223 Veihmeyer Hall
    LAWR Dept., UC Davis
    One Shields Avenue
    Davis, CA 95616
  • (530) 302-5658
  • (530) 752-1552
  • gpast@ucdavis.edu
  • Google Scholar
  • Research Gate
  • ORCID: 0000-0002-1977-4175
  • Dr. Gregory B. Pasternack - Watershed Hydrology, Geomorphology, and Ecohydraulics
UC Davis